Mr. Steak
https://mrsteak.com
Scorecard — Bench 1.0
5.5 [AGENT] agent-researched; turns green with user + third-party verification (rules)
| TASTE | 8.5 | Entire core line USDA Prime (top ~2% of US beef) with claimed 28-day wet aging; premium options include Japanese A5 Miyazaki ribeye and American Wagyu claimed BMS 8-9; 30-yr steakhouse-supply heritage. | |
| HEALTHY | 3.5 | No certifications; antibiotic/hormone policy undisclosed for core Prime line (RWA claims limited to American Wagyu line); pasture-raised-then-grain-fed self-claim; sourcing transparency decent (named packer, 250-mi Omaha radius). | |
| COST | 4.0 | Ribeye $59.93/lb entry (12oz $44.95), best $48.50/lb (8x20oz bone-in) — above the $25-45/lb D2C band even at bulk rates, though in-range for USDA Prime specifically; free shipping only at $325+. | |
| HAPPY | 3.0 | No welfare certification (AGA/GAP/Certified Humane absent). Self-claimed pasture raising and Temple Grandin-designed partner facility (Greater Omaha Packing) are positives but unaudited; grain finishing; no regenerative claims. | |
| TEXTURE | 8.2 | 28-day wet aging plus Prime-grade intramuscular fat supports tenderness; A5 and BMS 8-9 wagyu lines add ultra-tender options; no dry-aged program. |
Claims on file
| Attribute | Value | Verification | As of · sources |
|---|---|---|---|
| AGING | WET | SELF-CLAIMED · SELF | 2026-07-12 [1] · 'Each steak is wet-aged for 28-days and individually packaged' — 28-day wet aging claimed across the USDA Prime line. No dry-aged offering. |
| ANTIBIOTIC STATUS | RWA (SELF) | SELF-CLAIMED · SELF | 2026-07-12 [1] · American Wagyu line ONLY: 'no antibiotics ever', 'never-ever program', 100% vegetarian feed. Not claimed for the core Prime line. |
| ANTIBIOTIC STATUS | UNDISCLOSED | UNSTATED · SELF | 2026-07-12 [1] [2] · No antibiotic policy stated anywhere for the core USDA Prime line (checked home, About Us, collection and product pages). |
| HORMONE STATUS | UNDISCLOSED | UNSTATED · SELF | 2026-07-12 [1] [2] · No added-hormone statement for the core USDA Prime line anywhere on site. |
| HORMONE STATUS | NO-ADDED (SELF) | SELF-CLAIMED · SELF | 2026-07-12 [1] · American Wagyu line ONLY: 'no added hormones'. Not claimed for the core Prime line. |
| MARBLING | USDA PRIME | SELF-CLAIMED · SELF | 2026-07-12 [1] [2] · Core line Prime-grade marbling; American Wagyu claimed 'rated 8-9 on the Japanese BMS scale'; Japanese A5 'snowflake marbling'. |
| ORGANIC STATUS | NONE | UNSTATED · SELF | 2026-07-12 [1] [2] · No organic claims or USDA Organic certification anywhere on site. |
| RAISED CATEGORY | PASTURE·GRAIN-FIN | SELF-CLAIMED · SELF | 2026-07-12 [1] · About Us: 'Angus and Hereford Cattle are pasture raised and then fed a nutritious diet of locally grown alfalfa, corn, and grains.' |
| SOURCING | WITHIN 250 MI OF OMAHA, NE; PROCESSED BY GREATER OMAHA PACKING | SELF-CLAIMED · SELF | 2026-07-12 [1] · About Us: 'All of Mr. Steak's USDA Prime meats are sourced within a 250-mile radius of Omaha, Nebraska.' American Wagyu from US family farms; A5 from Miyazaki, Japan. |
| USDA GRADE | PRIME | SELF-CLAIMED · SELF | 2026-07-12 [1] [2] · Entire core line marketed as 'Top 2% USDA Prime'; no grade shield imagery verified. Japanese A5 and American Wagyu lines carry no USDA grade (BMS-rated instead). |
| WAGYU CONTENT | FULLBLOOD | SELF-CLAIMED · SELF | 2026-07-12 [1] · Japanese A5 Miyazaki line (fullblood Japanese Black by definition). Separate 'Natural American Wagyu' line pedigree unstated (likely influenced/cross), claimed BMS 8-9. |
| WELFARE CERT | NONE | UNSTATED · SELF | 2026-07-12 [1] · No third-party welfare cert (no AGA/AWA/GAP/Certified Humane). Site touts partner packer Greater Omaha Packing's Temple Grandin-designed facility — self-claimed, not a certification. |
■ registry/3P-certified · ◪ USDA paperwork · □ self-claimed. SELF = company statement (we trust and mark, per policy) · 3P = independent evidence — weighs most. Something wrong? Company representatives: a verified right-of-response slot ships at member launch; meanwhile email corrections with sources.
Buy
$48.50/lb bone-in as of 2026-07-12 · Best rate: 8x20oz bone-in $484.95 = $48.50/lb (sale, reg $74.95/steak). Single bone-in 20oz $69.95 = $55.96/lb; single boneless 12oz $44.95 = $59.93/lb; best boneless $56.24/lb (8x16oz $449.95).
VISIT SITE → SHOP BEEF →Unpaid links — we hold no affiliate relationship with Mr. Steak yet; if that changes the link will be marked [PAID LINK].
Ribeye sold
[BONELESS] [BONE-IN] [COWBOY] [AMERICAN-WAGYU] [JAPANESE-A5] [PRIME] [WET-AGED]
Other cuts
filet mignon · new york strip · bone-in new york strip · t-bone · porterhouse · flat iron · japanese a5 new york strip · wagyu burgers
Bundles
| USDA Prime Family Favorites Box | 2x8oz flat iron, 1x14oz NY strip (center cut), 1x10oz filet mignon (center cut), 1x12oz boneless ribeye, 2x8oz Wagyu burger patties; sale from $239.95 | $199.95 |
| Wagyu Wonderland Box | Wagyu assortment; contents not itemized on collection page; sale from $429.95 | $399.95 |