Evidence docket

Every fact, and where we read it

1,722 records behind the scores: what each seller says about its beef, the page we read it on, what we checked and found nothing, and every price change with its source. Nearly all of it is the sellers’ own words; we mark what isn’t. How we use it

All topics Grade 3 Aging 1 Herd: antibiotics, hormones, raising 8 Delivery & shipping 2 Prices 7 Origin 2 Other 1

All evidence Seller’s words 24 Checked: not stated 6 Weekly price check 5 Checked by hand 2 Certifier check 12

24 records match · clear filters.

Date	Seller · steak	Fact	What we record	Evidence	Source
Oct 6, 2026	44 Farms USDA Choice Tomahawk Ribeye	Size Seller’s words	Evidence attached to this steak	Checked 2026-10-06: the page says "Each Tomahawk Ribeye is hand cut to 32 oz" and "Approximately 32 oz"; 2 Count $220.00 ($110.00 per steak), so $55.00/lb. Our record had 48 oz, from the store's shipping weight for the 2… -count (6.0 lb), which includes packaging. Reported by Delmonico-bot's weekly check, 2026-10-05.	44steaks.com ↗
Oct 6, 2026	44 Farms All their beef	Raised Seller’s words		“At 44 Farms all cattle are pasture raised and grain finished.” (read 2026-10-06)	44steaks.com ↗
Oct 5, 2026	44 Farms USDA Choice Tomahawk Ribeye	Price basis Seller’s words	How we read the price and size	Weekly price check 2026-10-05 by Delmonico-bot: CHANGED $/lb. Live page: 2 Count $220.00 ($110.00/item); page now says "Each Tomahawk Ribeye is hand cut to 32 oz" (board uses 48 oz). $110 / 2.0 lb = $55.00/lb (was $36.67… /lb). Other packs: 4	44steaks.com ↗
Sep 28, 2026	44 Farms All their beef	Shipping Seller’s words	One-off or subscription	No shipping prices or free-shipping threshold are published (only "FedEx 1-2 day shipping"); in cart tests a $72 order to IL was quoted $29.95 Ground and a $274 order to CA shipped free.	44steaks.com ↗
Jul 13, 2026	44 Farms USDA Prime Boneless Ribeye Steak (12 oz)	Price basis Seller’s words	How we read the price and size	2-count/12oz variant = $84.00 (matches site '$42.00/item'); $84/2 = $42.00 per 12oz steak; 42.00 / (12/16=0.75) = $56.00/lb	44steaks.com ↗
Jul 13, 2026	44 Farms USDA Prime Boneless Ribeye Steak (16 oz)	Price basis Seller’s words	How we read the price and size	2-count/16oz variant = $112.00 (from product .json); $112/2 = $56.00 per 16oz steak; 56.00 / (16/16=1.0) = $56.00/lb	44steaks.com ↗
Jul 13, 2026	44 Farms USDA Choice Boneless Ribeye Steak (12 oz)	Price basis Seller’s words	How we read the price and size	2-count/12oz variant = $63.00 (matches site '$31.50/item'); $63/2 = $31.50 per 12oz steak; 31.50 / (12/16=0.75) = $42.00/lb	44steaks.com ↗
Jul 13, 2026	44 Farms USDA Choice Boneless Ribeye Steak (16 oz)	Price basis Seller’s words	How we read the price and size	2-count/16oz variant = $84.00 (from product .json); $84/2 = $42.00 per 16oz steak; 42.00 / (16/16=1.0) = $42.00/lb	44steaks.com ↗
Jul 13, 2026	44 Farms USDA Choice Bone-In Ribeye	Price basis Seller’s words	How we read the price and size	2-count variant = $128.00; $128/2 = $64.00 per steak. Per-steak weight from product .json weight field: 2-count pack = 5.0 lb total / 2 = 2.5 lb = 40 oz each (bone-in, includes bone). 64.00 / (40/16=2	44steaks.com ↗
Jul 13, 2026	44 Farms USDA Choice Tomahawk Ribeye	Price basis Seller’s words	How we read the price and size	2-count variant = $190.00; $190/2 = $95.00 per steak. Per-steak weight from product .json weight field: 2-count pack = 6.0 lb total / 2 = 3.0 lb = 48 oz each (tomahawk, sold bone-in incl. long frenche	44steaks.com ↗
Jul 13, 2026	44 Farms All their beef	Raised Seller’s words	Pasture-raised, grain-finished	FAQ: 'At 44 Farms all cattle are pasture raised and grain finished.' Confirmed.	44steaks.com ↗
Jul 13, 2026	44 Farms All their beef	Antibiotics Seller’s words	Raised without antibiotics	FAQ: animals not given antibiotics BUT if one becomes ill partner feedyards administer one, then remove it from the program. Their self-branded 'NE3' RWA, not a USDA never-ever cert.	44steaks.com ↗
Jul 13, 2026	44 Farms All their beef	Hormones Seller’s words	No added hormones	'NO ANTIBIOTICS OR ADDED HORMONES. EVER.'; self-claimed NE3, not NHTC/third-party verified. Confirmed.	44steaks.com ↗
Jul 13, 2026	44 Farms All their beef	Steroids Seller’s words	No steroids	No steroid-specific line, but 'no added hormones ever' (NE3) covers anabolic steroids as self-claim. No cert. Confirmed.	44steaks.com ↗
Jul 13, 2026	44 Farms All their beef	Diet Seller’s words	Vegetarian diet of grass and feed	Pasture (grass) then grain-finished; NE3 says no animal byproducts fed, so vegetarian grass+grain. Confirmed.	44steaks.com ↗
Jul 13, 2026	44 Farms All their beef	Origin Seller’s words	Product of USA	Raised in Cameron TX, harvested at Caviness in Hereford TX, but uses partner feedyards and no explicit born-raised-harvested claim. Downgraded from usa_born_raised_harvested.	44steaks.com ↗
Jul 13, 2026	44 Farms All their beef	Organic Seller’s words	None	No organic certification or claim on Our Story, Promise, or FAQ pages. Confirmed.	44farms.com ↗
Jul 13, 2026	44 Farms All their beef	Welfare Seller’s words	None	Markets 'ethically raised' but no third-party welfare cert (AWA/Certified Humane/GAP/American Humane/AGA) stated. Confirmed none.	44farms.com ↗
Jul 13, 2026	44 Farms All their beef	Delivery Seller’s words	Flash-frozen	FAQ: beef 'shipped vacuum sealed and frozen over dry ice'; store says steaks 'hand-cut, flash-frozen' via FedEx. No fresh option. Confirmed.	44steaks.com ↗
Jul 12, 2026	44 Farms All their beef	USDA grade Seller’s words	Choice	Benchmark SKU is USDA Choice ('USDA Choice Boneless Ribeye Steak'). Prime is a separate step-up SKU. Sold under USDA grading; no independent grading paperwork retrieved.	44steaks.com ↗ 44steaks.com ↗
Jul 12, 2026	44 Farms All their beef	Wagyu content Seller’s words	None	Benchmark is a Black Angus (Texas Angus) ribeye, not wagyu. 44 Farms is a registered Angus / Black Angus seedstock operation.	44steaks.com ↗ 44farms.com ↗
Jul 12, 2026	44 Farms All their beef	Marbling Seller’s words	Choice-level	Product page describes 'abundant intramuscular fat', 'signature buttery texture', tenderness and marbling; grade-level marbling = USDA Choice (self-asserted).	44steaks.com ↗
Jul 12, 2026	44 Farms All their beef	Aging Seller’s words	Wet-aged 28 days	'Wet Aged For 28 Days' on the product page; collection page states wet aged a minimum of 28 days.	44steaks.com ↗ 44steaks.com ↗
Jul 12, 2026	44 Farms All their beef	Sourcing Seller’s words	Single-source vertically integrated Texas Black Angus; Cameron, TX	5-generation registered Angus seedstock operation, Cameron TX; own cattle, hand-cut in Texas, own fulfillment center. BIF Seedstock Producer of the Year.	44farms.com ↗ 44steaks.com ↗