BEEF WIREmedian ribeye $57.23/lblow $11.99/lb Wild Fork Foods29 sellers ranked393 claims on fileprices checked Nov 9
beefshopper
Log inJoin free
Menu
RibeyesSellersBundlesGuidesHow we scoreNewsletterLog inJoin free

ButcherBox

Thick Cut Ribeye (18 oz)

UngradedBonelessShips frozenGrass-fed and grass-finished
4.6$29.33/lb#29 of 51Buy ↗
Illustration, not a product photo.

Score breakdown

Why it scores 4.6

Price$29.33/lb scores 7.9, +2.2 for its cut: under the $45.88 median of ungraded ribeyes with no aging stated, capped at 10. It counts 37%: price counts in full only when grade and aging together score 7 or more, and this steak’s come to 2.610.0×30%
AgingAging not stated: scored as days not stated; no dry-aging premium3.0×25%
GradeUSDA grade or Wagyu grade, for taste2.0×20%
Antibiotics and hormonesAntibiotics: none ever · added hormones: none added9.0×15%
RaisingThis listing says grass-fed and grass-finished; Certified Humane adds9.8×10%

On the board: Cut +1.2 (grade and aging) · Herd +2.3 (antibiotics, hormones, raising, organic and ethics) · Price +1.1 = 4.6.

Maxed out: Price. Lowest: Grade 2.0, Aging 3.0.

The facts

Read from the listing and ButcherBox’s own pages by the phrase dictionary 1.17, Nov 12, 2026. A listing’s own words come first; then what the seller says of all its beef. How facts are read

Grade
Not stated on this listing or by ButcherBox
Aging
Not stated on this listing or by ButcherBox
Raised on
Grass-fed and grass-finished
This listing says: Our 100% grass-fed thick cut ribeye steak is incredibly tender and juicy. … 100% Grass-Fed … Pasture-Raised shop.butcherbox.com ↗
Organic
Not stated on this listing or by ButcherBox
Antibiotics
None ever
ButcherBox, of all its beef: All products have no antibiotics or added hormones butcherbox.com ↗
Hormones
None added
ButcherBox, of all its beef: All products have no antibiotics or added hormones butcherbox.com ↗
Welfare
Certified Humane Confirmed on the certifier’s own list
On the certifier’s own list:
Certified Humane — Certified Humane Raised and Handled: listed (checked 2026-10-06). “ButcherBox | By subscription ButcherBox Grass-fed: Beef, Pork, and Bison” Own company row 'ButcherBox' (website ButcherBox.com) lists show more grass-fed beef. Also named in other companies' rows for beef: Branding Iron Holdings Inc. ('Butcher Box: Grass-Fed Ground Beef Patties ... Seasoned Grass-fed Ground Beef for Meatlo
certifiedhumane.org ↗
Origin
Australia
This listing says: Product of Australia shop.butcherbox.com ↗ ButcherBox sells beef from more than one country (our July research), so this listing’s own words count.

This steak

Cut
Boneless · 18 oz
Same row
Ribeyes (10 oz, $30.80/lb)
Listings of the same grade, aging, bone and raising share one row on the board, named after the best-scoring one.
Price
$33.00 a steak · $29.33/lb
Stock
In stock at last check
Shipping
Free shipping on every order
“Subscription boxes only (plans from $159), and "shipping's always on us" on every box.” source, checked Sep 28, 2026
How you buy
Subscription only — Subscription boxes only (plans from $159).

Also on file · all ButcherBox beef

Delivery
Frozen

Comparison

Where it sits on the board

Cheaper per pound than all 7 other ungraded ribeyes with no aging stated we track; their median is $45.88/lb. Pat LaFrieda Meat Purveyors’s Prime Boneless Ribeye Steak, Dry-Aged 30 Days, below, isn’t one of them: it’s Prime.

$20$40$60$80$100$120median $45.88 this steak $29.33
#29 · this steakButcherBox · Thick Cut Ribeye
Score7.74.6
GradePrimeUngraded
AgingDry · 30 dNot stated
$/lb$52.81$29.33
AntibioticsNone everNone ever
DeliveryFreshFrozen

Highlighted rows differ. Pat LaFrieda Meat Purveyors scores higher on Aging, Grade; this steak scores higher on Price score, Raising.

Price history

Every day we've checked this steak's price, every change, and every weekly check that couldn’t confirm it. Change is per pound, so a size correction shows.

$31$27 JulNov $29.33
CheckedHowSizePrice$/lbChangeStock
Nov 9, 2026Weekly check18 oz$33.00$29.33—In stock
Nov 2, 2026Weekly check18 oz$33.00$29.33—In stock
Oct 27, 2026Weekly check18 oz$33.00$29.33—In stock
Oct 19, 2026Weekly check18 oz$33.00$29.33—In stock
Oct 12, 2026Weekly check18 oz$33.00$29.33—In stock
Oct 5, 2026Weekly check18 oz$33.00$29.33—In stock
Sep 28, 2026Weekly check (2 checks that day)18 oz$33.00$29.33—In stock
Jul 13, 2026Our July research
$33.00 a steak of 18 oz is $29.33/lb. Research note: Single steak, 18 oz, $33.00 (1 steak per package, no count division needed). usd_per_lb = 33.00 / (18/16) = 33.00 / 1.125 = $29.33/lb.		18 oz$33.00$29.33In stock

Evidence All evidence for this steak →

KindCoversSource
Checked: not statedGradeshop.butcherbox.com ↗
Checked 2026-09-30: no grade stated. Pages: https://shop.butcherbox.com/market/products/thick-cut-ribeye https://www.butcherbox.com/pages/faqs show more https://www.butcherbox.com/pages/sourcing https://www.butcherbox.com/pages/about-us https://support.butcherbox.com/hc/en-us (help-center article search: aged, graded, grade, dry aged, USDA, beef, ribeye, grain finished; incl. 'Can you tell me about your beef?') https://justcook.butcherbox.com (ButcherBox blog search: wet aged, graded)
Checked: not statedAgingshop.butcherbox.com ↗
Checked 2026-09-30: aging not stated. Pages: https://shop.butcherbox.com/market/products/thick-cut-ribeye https://www.butcherbox.com/pages/faqs show more https://www.butcherbox.com/pages/sourcing https://www.butcherbox.com/pages/about-us https://support.butcherbox.com/hc/en-us (help-center article search: aged, graded, grade, dry aged, USDA, beef, ribeye, grain finished; incl. 'Can you tell me about your beef?') https://justcook.butcherbox.com (ButcherBox blog search: wet aged, graded)
Seller’s page
Superseded		Productshop.butcherbox.com ↗ Single steak, 18 oz, $33.00 (1 steak per package, no count division needed). usd_per_lb = 33.00 / (18/16) = 33.00 / 1.125 = $29.33/lb.
Seller’s pageProductshop.butcherbox.com ↗ Weekly price check 2026-10-05 by Delmonico-bot: UNCHANGED. Live page: 18 oz pack $33.00 ($29.33/lb), not sold out.
Seller’s pageRaised Categoryshop.butcherbox.com ↗ “Our 100% grass-fed thick cut ribeye steak is incredibly tender and juicy. / 100% Grass-Fed / Pasture-Raised” (read 2026-10-06)

Price checks and corrections

Is this steak’s price, size, aging or grade on the seller’s page the same as ours, or different? Tell us, with a link or a screenshot.

Log in to propose a correction.

Keep comparing

Similar steaks, ranked

Full board
$16/lbchecked 4 days ago5.117DAYS WET
Wild Fork Foods

Organic Ribeye Steak

Deduction for limited delivery options: Local delivery only, free over $35
UngradedFlash-frozen
Boneless · 7.84 ozBuy ↗