Home-delivery ribeye steaks, ranked by value

Every steak from 29 sellers, scored on aging, price per pound, a clean herd, how the cattle were raised and grade.

Herd 4+ of 4 Price $$ or cheaper Grass-fed and grass-finished Clear all

# is each steak’s rank on the full board of 51.

+1.9 Click a number to see how it was scored A third party confirms it The seller says it Not stated

#	Purveyor — steak	Cut	HerdRaised onAntibioticsHormonesOrganicEthicsA third party confirms itThe seller says itNot stated	Price	Buy
29	ButcherBox — Thick Cut RibeyeBoneless · 10 · 18 ozFrozen · Ships free · Subscription only	Ungraded Aging not statedAustralia	Raised on: Grass · grass-finished Antibiotics: None ever Hormones: None added Organic: Not organicEthics: Certified Humane	$29–31/lb49% under medianchecked 4 days ago	Buy ↗
31	Rastellis — Grass-Fed RibeyeBoneless · 10 ozFlash-frozen · Ships free over $199	Ungraded Aging not stated	Raised on: Grass · grass-finished Antibiotics: None ever Hormones: None added Organic: Not organicEthics: No certification	$32/lb44% under medianchecked 4 days ago	Buy ↗
32	D’Artagnan — Grass-Fed Beef Ribeye Steak (4-count)Boneless · 12 ozFrozen · Ships free over $199	Ungraded Aging not statedAustralia	Raised on: Grass · grass-finished Antibiotics: None ever Hormones: None added Organic: Not organicEthics: Certified Humane	$33/lb42% under medianchecked 4 days ago	Buy ↗
38	Crowd Cow — Grass-Fed Ribeye Steak (Frigorifico Pando, Uruguay, boneless)Boneless · 16 ozFlash-frozen · Ships free over $149	Ungraded Aged, method not statedUruguay	Raised on: Grass · grass-finished Antibiotics: None ever Hormones: None added Organic: Not organicEthics: No certification	$42/lb26% under medianchecked 4 days ago	Buy ↗
40	Primal Pastures — Ribeye SteakBoneless · 10 ozFlash-frozen · Ships free over $239	Ungraded Aging not statedUSA	Raised on: Grass · grass-finished Antibiotics: None ever Hormones: None added Organic: Not organicEthics: No certification	$48/lb16% under medianchecked 4 days ago	Buy ↗
47	White Oak Pastures — Tomahawk Ribeye SteakTomahawk · 32 ozFrozen · Ships free over $249	Ungraded Not agedUSA	Raised on: Grass · grass-finished Antibiotics: None ever Hormones: None added Organic: Not organicEthics: AGA Certified Grassfed, Certified Humane	$40/lb30% under medianchecked 4 days ago	Buy ↗
↳	Grassfed Beef Ribeye Steak (Bone-In)Bone-in · 16 oz	Ungraded Not agedUSA	Same herd as above	$41/lb28% under medianchecked 4 days ago	Buy ↗
↳	Grassfed Beef Ribeye Steak (Boneless)Boneless · 8 · 14 oz	Ungraded Not agedUSA	Same herd as above	$46–47/lb20% under medianchecked 4 days ago	Buy ↗

+1.9 Click a number to see how it was scored A third party confirms it The seller says it Not stated

Sold out for six weeks or more (17), not ranked

A steak that’s been sold out at every price check for more than six weeks (seen on at least three days) leaves the ranking. It comes back as soon as a check finds it in stock.

Holy Grail Steak Co. — Upper Prime Black Angus Ribeye $69.00/lb · sold out at all 8 checks since Jul 13, 2026
Holy Grail Steak Co. — Australian Wagyu Ribeye - MB 6-7 $89.00/lb · sold out at all 8 checks since Jul 13, 2026
Holy Grail Steak Co. — Tajima American Wagyu Prestige Ribeye Steak $99.00/lb · sold out at all 8 checks since Jul 13, 2026
Holy Grail Steak Co. — Dry-Aged Upper Prime Black Angus Ribeye Steaks $99.00/lb · sold out at all 8 checks since Jul 13, 2026
Holy Grail Steak Co. — Australian Wagyu Ribeye - MB 8-9 $107.20/lb · sold out at all 8 checks since Jul 13, 2026
Holy Grail Steak Co. — BMS 12 Kagoshima Japanese A5 Wagyu Ribeye $199.00/lb · sold out at all 8 checks since Jul 13, 2026
Holy Grail Steak Co. — BMS 12 Hokkaido Japanese A5 Wagyu Ribeyes $209.00/lb · sold out at all 8 checks since Jul 13, 2026
Holy Grail Steak Co. — BMS 12 Miyazaki Japanese A5 Wagyu Ribeyes $249.00/lb · sold out at all 8 checks since Jul 13, 2026
Holy Grail Steak Co. — Kobe Japanese A5 Wagyu Ribeye ~14 $372.27/lb · sold out at all 8 checks since Jul 13, 2026
Holy Grail Steak Co. — BMS 12 Kobe Japanese A5 Wagyu Ribeye $456.00/lb · sold out at all 8 checks since Jul 13, 2026
Mr. Steak — Natural American Wagyu Ribeye $66.66/lb · sold out at all 8 checks since Jul 13, 2026
Omaha Steaks — Private Reserve Wagyu Ribeyes $111.11/lb · sold out at all 4 checks since Sep 28, 2026
Omaha Steaks — KING CUT: Ribeye on the Bone (single steak) $120.00/lb · sold out at all 5 checks since Sep 28, 2026
Porter Road — Thick Cut Boneless Ribeye (Dry Aged) $47.74/lb · sold out at all 8 checks since Jul 13, 2026
Porter Road — Thick Cut Bone-In Ribeye (Dry Aged) $50.48/lb · sold out at all 7 checks since Sep 28, 2026
Rastellis — Organic Grass-Fed Ribeye $27.99/lb · sold out at all 8 checks since Jul 13, 2026
Snake River Farms — Wagyu Ribeye Steak - SRF Black 1.5" $89.00/lb · sold out at all 7 checks since Sep 28, 2026

Prices checked Nov 9, 2026, weekly; every change is kept in each steak's price history. Weights: price 30 · aging 25 · grade 20 · healthy 15 · raising 10; an organic steak adds 0.2. Each steak’s +numbers add up to its score; click one to see how. Each steak is one purveyor’s ribeyes in one grade group (Prime, Choice, Wagyu, ungraded): its best version is ranked, and its other versions and sizes open under it. Price tiers, by quarter of the board: $ up to $38 · $$ $38–53 · $$$ $53–66 · $$$$ over $66 per lb. 1 listing hidden (no published price). Every rule, in the scoring canon.